Amy Robach Reportedly Blindsided By T.J. Holmes' Affairs

Amy Robach didn't expect T.J. Holmes to have previous office scandals, according to reports.

Robach and Holmes have both been suspended from "GMA3" following their affair scandal in November 2022. The pair has been spotted out and about together. They even spent the holidays in Atlanta and Miami together.

However, Robach reportedly felt "blindsided" by the reports about Holmes' office scandals, Page Six reported. But, one source said she was not surprised by at least one of his previous romances — his relationship with producer Natasha Singh.

The insider claimed that Holmes was "up front" with Robach about his flame with Singh. However, she wasn't aware of his other office romances.

Another insider spoke about the same issue with The Sun. The tipster claimed that Robach didn't expect Holmes to have other office romances. The 45-year-old journalist reportedly had a months-long affair with an intern 13 years her senior, Jasmin Pettaway, then 24. They reportedly had sex in his office while on the job.

"She had no idea the scope of TJ's alleged past office romances," an insider told The Sun about Robach. "She certainly did not foresee that their relationship was going to cause major upheaval - outside of her own marriage. She did not expect this to blow up into a scandal."

The insider claimed that ABC is also investigating Robach's past for some scandal. Fortunately, she is "well-behaved."

When Holmes and Robach's affair made headlines, another insider told Page Six that his wife, Marilee Fiebig, was "blindsided." The immigration lawyer and the TV anchor were reportedly trying to "work things out" and even spent his birthday in the Bahamas with their daughter, Sabine, 8.

"She's devastated. She had no idea," the source said of Fiebig. "They haven't been together in [a while], but they were trying to work it out."

Fiebig was allegedly focused on her husband's affair with Singh that she never suspected something was going on between the "GMA3" co-anchors.

"Marilee never considered Amy because she was focused on Natasha. She never thought about [him cheating] with Amy because they were friends. Amy's daughter was their daughter's babysitter," the source claimed.

Holmes and Robach were seen arriving in New York City after their Christmas trip. An insider claimed they were "sticking together" and were already "fully in a relationship."

The pair reportedly lost many friends and co-workers following their affair and couldn't talk to them, so they decided to be there for each other.

"Amy and T.J. are sticking together and putting on a united front. They really only have each other right now," a source told Us Weekly.