Taylor Swift Was Called A 'Silence Breaker' To The Disappointment Of Many
Time Magazine's "Person of the Year" was confirmed Wednesday as "The Silence Breakers," a group of influential women who came forward with stories of sexual harassment and assault. Singer Taylor Swift was featured as one of the five women on the magazine's cover, prompting criticism from some on social media.
Time's cover pays tribute to the anti-harassment movement that has drawn headlines throughout 2017. The movement was sparked in October after decades-old allegations of sexual misconduct from more than 50 women surfaced against movie producer Harvey Weinstein. The movement led many notable women from a variety of industries to speak out about their experiences, including the four featured with Swift on the cover: Ashley Judd, Susan Fowler, Adama Iwu and Isabel Pascual.
Taylor Swift? pic.twitter.com/54HYA9z1lN
— Mike Cernovich __ (@Cernovich) December 6, 2017
Swift had brought her harassment battle to the public by going to trial against Denver-based DJ David Mueller, who allegedly groped her backstage at a meet-and-greet in Colorado. Critics wrote that they didn't "understand" the publication's decision to have Swift on the cover, with one noting, "she remains silent on literally everything." Some even suggested more drastic measures, such as calling for a "petition to replace Taylor Swift's spot."
petition to replace taylor swift's spot on the cover of time with one of the nuns from the keepers
— Anna Fitzpatrick (@bananafitz) December 6, 2017
and I don't understand how they chose Taylor Swift over Rose McGowan for the #metoo cover photo
— Katy Stoll (@katystoll) December 6, 2017
how is taylor swift a ~silence breaker~ when she remains silent on literally everything
— celebrity boyfriend (@geekygare) December 6, 2017
Stop it. Just. Stop. Nobody is saying Taylor Swift wasn't victimized. Nobody is saying Taylor Swift doesn't deserve to speak about her experience. People are just wondering why she was picked to be the face of a movement over the woman who ACTUALLY CREATED THE MOVEMENT.
— _️_Jenny Trout (@Jenny_Trout) December 6, 2017
4. I know Taylor Swift was included on the cover to sell magazines, and I'm not going to take away from anyone's experience, but she has never posted on her powerful social media platforms about #metoo - not even once.
— Yashar Ali _ (@yashar) December 6, 2017
Im sorry, but Taylor Swift has remained incredibly silent the last year while the political landscape has been taken over by incredible women. She does not deserve to be on the @TIME cover when there are so many others who spoke out.
— Nicole Sievers (@SickNastNicole) December 6, 2017
Taylor Swift on the cover of a magazine celebrating women (and men) who courageously told their stories at real costs to their livelihoods and safety is such a slap in the face.
— Candice Marie Benbow (@CandiceBenbow) December 6, 2017
Some social media users did come to Swift's defense. Many cited her sexual harassment trial against Mueller and paying the legal expenses for singer Kesha's lawsuit against her former producer Dr. Luke as a reason for why she deserved to be featured on Time's cover.
Taylor Swift not speaking up on some issues or putting out music you don’t like doesn’t mean you get to decide her brave public sexual assault trial was meaningless.
— Alex Goldschmidt (@alexandergold) December 6, 2017
I will not let anyone disrespect Taylor Swift for being on the TIME’s Person of the Year. She is a SILENCE BREAKER. She FOUGHT and WON against the person who sexually harassed her. She inspired women to speak out and fight against sexual assaults.
— allain __ (@swiftreputation) December 6, 2017
For anyone wondering why Taylor swift deserves to be featured in that Time's article. #TheSilenceBreakers pic.twitter.com/peTBdmQMyI
— Sara Clevenger (@SaraClevenger) December 6, 2017
taylor swift’s symbolic $1 win on her own sexual assault was important. not to mention the support she gave to kesha. y’all can call her many things but she was apart of the silence breakers movement.
— ❦ (@fkajack) December 6, 2017
Reasons why Taylor Swift is TIME's Person of the Year:
— Taylor Swift Facts (@TSwiftFCT) December 6, 2017
- She stood up against sexual assault (and won)
- She countersued only for $1 and made her point
- She helped other victims to raise their voice
- She showed her financial support for other victims (like Kesha) #TIMEPOY pic.twitter.com/nRJLpIvlER
In a statement published Wednesday on Time's website, Editor-in-Chief Edward Felsenthal explained why the women featured in the story and on the cover were chosen. Felsenthal had even referred to Swift's court case as "raw" and "defiant."
"It became a hashtag, a movement, a reckoning. But it began, as great social change nearly always does, with individual acts of courage," Felsenthal said. "The galvanizing actions of the women on our cover — Ashley Judd, Susan Fowler, Adama Iwu, Taylor Swift and Isabel Pascual —along with those of hundreds of others, and of many men as well, have unleashed one of the highest-velocity shifts in our culture since the 1960s."
'I was angry.' @taylorswift13 on what powered her sexual assault testimony #TIMEPOY https://t.co/MYHHwtRocJ pic.twitter.com/TQ3jnTpACD
— TIME (@TIME) December 6, 2017
Swift isn't typically outspoken on social issues, which has been a criticism of the 27-year-old pop star. However, she detailed her experience with Mueller in court. She won the case in August, but only requested to be paid $1 for Mueller's misconduct — a compensation she has revealed to have not yet received.
"I was angry. In that moment, I decided to forego any courtroom formalities and just answer the questions the way it happened," Swift told Time. "This man hadn’t considered any formalities when he assaulted me, and his lawyer didn’t hold back on my mom — why should I be polite?"
"I'm told it was the most amount of times the word 'ass' has ever been said in Colorado Federal Court," Swift added.
© Copyright IBTimes 2024. All rights reserved.