What's Next For Dylann Roof? Death Penalty Sentence Possible After Charleston Shooter Found Guilty Of Murder

A jury in the federal trial of 22-year-old white supremacist shooter Dylann Roof, who opened fire last summer on a group of black congregants at the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina, found him guilty of all 33 federal counts Thursday afternoon.
Roof likely faces the death penalty at his sentencing hearing on Jan. 3.
After initially asking Judge Richard Gergel if he could represent himself, Roof backtracked, opting for a lawyer during the guilt portion of the hearing. For the sentencing portion, however, he will appear without an attorney.
The jury, selected a week prior to the sentencing portion of the hearing, consisted of two black women, eight white women, one white man and one black man.
The verdict ended a stretch of emotional testimony, including the recording of a 911 call made by survivor Polly Sheppard, a 72-year-old Emanuel AME congregant. In her witness testimony, Sheppard recalled that Roof told her on the night of the shooting that he would spare her life, so that she could live “to tell the story.”
Sheppard says she can hear someone coming; 911 operator tells her to be quiet. Then, "What's going on Ms. Polly?" dispatcher asks.#RoofTrial
— Carter Coyle (@CarterCoyleMUSC) December 14, 2016
Dylann Roof to Polly Sheppard: “Did I shoot you yet?... “I’m not going to. I need you to tell the story.” https://t.co/dUMAqHzGEJ pic.twitter.com/v71oPQ7f6E
— The Daily Beast (@thedailybeast) December 15, 2016
Jurors also watched Roof’s confession video, in which he laughed as he admitted to the shooting the congregants.
"I did it," Dylann Roof told FBI agents. Then he laughed. Watch the entire confession video here: https://t.co/4pdv4rIkF9. #RoofTrial pic.twitter.com/XRyHwMz8uK
— The Post and Courier (@postandcourier) December 10, 2016
Roof’s attorney David Bruck pushed for a life sentence, as opposed to the death penalty, in his arguments Thursday morning and claimed that the Columbia native had been motivated by fear rather than hate. The gunman, Bruck argued, held a contorted view of reality and had been radicalized by the racist things he’d grown up reading in books and online.
"There is something wrong with his perception. There is something wrong with what he is perceiving about reality" -Bruck abt #DylannRoof
— Abigail Darlington (@A_Big_Gail) December 15, 2016
Now, he pulls up this picture - demonstrating how Roof emulated the book. #sctweets @wis10 #DylannRoof #RoofTrial pic.twitter.com/RwZaDVpGV8
— Chad K. Mills (@ChadKMills) December 15, 2016
#DylannRoof "gave whole life to a belief ... that there is a fight between white people and black people that is being covered up" -Bruck
— Abigail Darlington (@A_Big_Gail) December 15, 2016
Federal prosecutors, on the other hand, turned this argument on its head, describing Roof as a martyr for a racist, hateful cause. Roof’s eagerness to confess, as shown in the video, was evidence of not mental illness, but rather his extremist racial hatred, Assistant U.S. Attorney Nathan Williams argued.
"Racial zealots still exist," the prosecutor says. "People who are willing to be martyred." #sctweets @wis10 #DylannRoof #RoofTrial
— Chad K. Mills (@ChadKMills) December 15, 2016
"We all have access to the internet." The choice he made was to believe it and act on it. #EmanuelAME #DylannRoof #chsnews @WCBD
— Ashley Rae Osborne (@TodaywAshleyRae) December 15, 2016
He says the video shows that "mental illness had nothing to do" with this crime. #sctweets @wis10 #DylannRoof #RoofTrial
— Chad K. Mills (@ChadKMills) December 15, 2016
Roof still faces a state trial on 13 charges, including nine for murder, on Jan. 17. Like their federal counterparts, state prosecutors will also pursue the death penalty.
© Copyright IBTimes 2024. All rights reserved.