Best SEO Companies in Indianapolis, IN 2025
Hiring an SEO company is a vital step for businesses to gain online traffic, boost brand awareness, and capture a wider market while increasing conversion rates. In fact, 85% of global search traffic belongs to Google, while the remaining comes from other search engines like Yahoo!, Baidu, and Bing.
Businesses need to know how to deal with the algorithm of these platforms so their website appears on the first page of search results, and in the process, attracts visitors that convert to sales and long-term clients. SEO companies are the key to transforming an unknown business into a popular brand.
However, choosing a firm should be done with extreme caution as most (if not all) claim to be the best. Hire one that has a proven track record, experience, and offered services needed by businesses.
Here are five of the best SEO companies in Indianapolis.
Best SEO Companies in Indianapolis, IN 2025
The Web Guys
The Web Guys has been at the forefront of the digital marketing revolution since 2005 by offering web design and search marketing services to clients in Indianapolis. As a testament to their success, the company recently expanded its operations to cater to the surrounding states.
They are focused on improving the quality of their client’s brand while increasing sales and market coverage. The firm says that this is vital to dominate and control the target market.
The services they offer are web design, SEM, SEO, email marketing, and social media management. They also offer strategic consultation as an added bonus.
The Web Guys is accredited by the Better Business Bureau and a member of the Indiana Chamber of Commerce. It also got featured in UpCity after developing sales-raking websites and valuable promotional content to clients from the construction, enterprise, and rental industries.
Ever Effect
EverEffect is a digital marketing company that focuses on providing SEO services to clients through a simple yet effective process that searches, analyzes, and converts clients online.
Members of this firm are certified experts in interactive development, strategic planning, and data analysis, which isn’t surprising knowing that they are among the first to use online streaming for marketing purposes in the area.
EverEffect provides digital marketing services in the fields of SEO, PPC, social media, and email. Furthermore, the company offers web design and development, video production, and web analytics services to businesses wishing to improve online presence. They even offer a free site evaluation for frequent and first-time clients.
EverEffect recently became a Premier Google Partner after finishing projects for numerous Fortune 500 companies with excellent and satisfactory results.
Punch Bug Marketing
Businesses looking to work with a digital marketing agency that combines compelling design and creative content can turn to Punch Bug Marketing. It is a full-on SEO company that creates marketing strategies to promote businesses online.
The firm's one-on-one data-driven approach speeds up clients’ sales increase and brand recognition.
The digital marketing services offered are web design and development, email marketing, SEO, and graphic design. They do this by implementing cost-effective strategies that maximize resources. This way, clients can cut on costs without compromising quality.
Some of the firm’s most notable clients are finance consulting firm ProAction Group, Top Shelf Tours, a travel agency, and RECI, a software company renowned in the local tech sector.
Punch Bug Marketing has won numerous awards as well, including the 2020 Top 3 Web Designers in Indianapolis and UpCity’s Marketplace Top Creative Agency.
Ay Okay
Ay Okay is a full-service digital agency focusing on improving businesses to attain new and better markets through an extensive SEO and web development campaign.
The agency's open-minded approach combined with using state-of-the-art tech and strategies ensure quick and long-term growth.
Some of the advanced services offered by Ay Okay are site architecture planning, brand strategy and development, app creation, and e-commerce optimization.
Meanwhile, its middle-tier offerings include website maintenance, web design and development, SEO, and social media marketing.
Their notable clients are established businesses in the food and furniture industries such as Zespri Kiwifruit, Family Leisure, and Pig’s Tale Charcuterie, with whom they created websites for and increased SEO rankings.
Element Three
An Indianapolis-based digital marketing agency founded in 2006, Element Three is one of the most trusted firms in Indianapolis when it comes to improving business branding through an aggressive digital marketing campaign.
The ADDY award-winning company features a simple yet highly-effective process when tackling a client’s marketing issues. They do this by researching, planning, then implementing basic and advanced SEO strategies.
The company offers web design, brand development, and multichannel marketing alongside their traditional video production service.
Their most notable clients come from the tech, outdoor, and specialty healthcare industries like BraunAbility, Newmar RV travel, and Airstream. However, the agency has been accepting clients from other industries lately, including startups and SMEs.
They also won the 2015 National Creative Advertising and 2019 Indianapolis ADDYs Best of Show awards.