Neil deGrasse Tyson Analyzes Some ‘Game Of Thrones’ Science On Twitter

For a story based on magic and dragons and the undead, you wouldn’t ordinarily expect someone to analyze it from a scientific point of view. But what if that someone happened to be both a “Game of Thrones” fan as well as an astrophysicist? Cue Neil deGrasse Tyson.
The well-known scientist took to his Twitter account Sunday to post some comments about some of the science in the show, complete with screenshots from episodes, leading to hundreds of reactions.
Everybody all caught up on #GameOfThrones? I have a comment or two, if anybody is interested…
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
I thought the frozen dead dudes couldn’t swim, but aside from that…
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
First on deGrasse Tyson’s list of things to talk about — the only example of bad physics he cites, in fact — were the much-talked about chains that the White Walkers used to drag Viserion’s body out of the lake, after it was killed by the Night King and before being resurrected. Unlike many others who, when the episode aired, were wondering where those heavy-duty chains came from, deGrasse Tyson questioned the physics behind the use of chains to pulling something — a dragon out of a lake, in this case — as shown in the episode.
Bad Physics in #GameOfThrones: Pulling a dragon out of a lake? Chains need to be straight, and not curve over hill and dale. pic.twitter.com/VIJlIuDz3L
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
The scientist seemed quite content with the dragons themselves though, at least insofar as their wings are concerned.
Good Bio-Physics in #GameOfThrones: The Dragon Wingspans are sensibly large, as their body weight would require for flight. pic.twitter.com/gzD5wI38u5
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
Good Biology in #GameOfThrones: As in #LordOfTheRings, Dragons forfeited their forelimbs to make wings, like birds & bats. pic.twitter.com/pguBe6rosQ
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
And speaking of wings, he also turned a critical eye on the cherubs often shown in Renaissance-period art.
The sensibly large wingspan of Dragons in #GameOfThrones contrasts with aerodynamically useless wings of Renaissance cherubs. pic.twitter.com/I8L8ILBtUu
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
He may also have provided a scientific explanation for why the now-undead dragon Viserion, now spitting blue fire instead of the usual red-and-yellow, had such an easy time bringing down the Wall which had stood the test of time for however long it had been standing there.
Intriguing Thermal Physics in #GameOfThrones: BlueDragon breath would be at least a factor of 3X hotter than RedDragon breath pic.twitter.com/RvpBkqJ1sw
— Neil deGrasse Tyson (@neiltyson) September 24, 2017
The science ended there, but Twitter users had a multitude of reactions to the posts — ranging from those engaging with them scientifically to those dismissing them as being out of touch with magic, and to the usual funny ones.
Or is it burning an element that produces a blue spectrum - copper or arsenic for instance? pic.twitter.com/Rh0eKpl4Oy
— A-Level Physics HQ (@ALevelPhysicsHQ) September 25, 2017
Those chains are probably heavier than the dragon, so their own weight is not a force we can neglect in this problem. #BecausePhysics
— Daniel Toledo (@DaniToledoMelg) September 25, 2017
Where did the chains come from and as they can't swim who put the chains on the dragon?
— Karen Bagguley (she/her) (@KarenBagguley) September 25, 2017
They also take off wrong. Like bats and pterosaurs,the dragons should launch themselves, quadrupedally, from a standing start w/ their wings
— Patrick Murphy (@prasokour) September 24, 2017
@neiltyson what liquid or gas do you suppose would create such heat in normal atmospheric conditions?
— Garet Watters (@gmanska) September 25, 2017
Ah-HA, Dr Tyson has fallen prey to the frailty of logic, and THAT is, logic holds NO sway over magic, or magical creatures.
— Nermal_Said (@Nermal_Said) September 25, 2017
Psssst, dragons is not for real 😉
— Trine (@PrmTrine) September 25, 2017
i think they have diffrent laws there, you know magic, dragons, zombies etc.
— CicoPhicho (@CPhicho) September 25, 2017
Magic chains
— timo (@zeno_e) September 25, 2017
It seems tension is nonexistent in Game of Thrones, literally and figuratively. 😊
— чистосердечный (@LeptonDecay) September 25, 2017
So it was fire indeed. He is upgraded version with hotter fire and faster speed
— Arslan Ejaz (@ArslanLion1996) September 25, 2017
And there was at least person who said George R.R. Martin, the author who wrote the books the show is based on, would likely be very interested getting the science right.
GRRM is a sci-fi writer tho. He spent 30 years writing sci-fi stories, he cares about all this and we should care too but the show doesn't
— OLI (@Oli_Brazier) September 25, 2017
So while you wait for the next, and last, season to unfold next summer here’s something to think about.
© Copyright IBTimes 2024. All rights reserved.